PIE

Author: Sarah Weeks

Publisher: Scholastic Press

Publication Year: 2011

Most of the readers will be: 4th-7th grade girls.

Reader's Advisory: Another charming historical fiction novel that has been a Georgia Book Award Nominee is The Luck of the Buttons by Anne Ylvisaker.

Summary:
Alice's Aunt Polly put Ipswitch on the map with her award-winning pies. Now Polly has passed away and she left her secret-pie crust recipe to her cat, Lardo. And she left Lardo to Alice. As Alice tries to deal with the loss of her beloved Aunt and tries to convince her parents not to get rid of Lardo, she realizes that someone is trying to steal the recipe. But, even Alice doesn't know where it is. After all, how do you leave a recipe to a cat?
And for all the readers out there who are also bakers, a different pie recipe precedes each chapter.

My favorite passage:

The next stop was the parsonage, where they found Reverend Flowers in his kitchen with a dish towel tied around his waist.
"Good gravy, what happened to you?" Charlie exclaimed when he saw the Reverend's red fingertips. "Did you cut yourself or something?"
"Cherries," said the Reverend, wiggling his stained fingers to demonstrate that they were all still working. "I had no idea how much work it was going to be to pit them."
"Aunt Polly taught me a little trick about pitting cherries," said Alice. "Use a paper clip. You just unfold it, stick it in, and pull the pit right out."
"How ingenious!" cried Reverend Flowers. "I can hardly wait to try it."
"Do you mind if I offer you another piece of advice?" Alice asked politely. "You might not remember this, but Aunt Polly won the Blueberry for her cherry pie last year. As far as I know, they've never given the prize to the same kind of pie two years in a row."
Reverend Flowers smiled and put his hand on Alice's shoulder.
"I've heard that there are some folks in town who've set their sights on winning the Blueberry this year, now that Polly's not here to do it, but I'm not one of them. Your aunt was a remarkable person and I miss her dearly. I got to thinking about her today and for some reason it made me want to make a cherry pie."
Alice felt better somehow knowing that the reason Reverend Flowers was baking a pie was because he missed Aunt Polly. (pg 148-149)

What I really think:
I have a hard time getting into historical fiction sometimes and I think many of my students do, also. This book is light and fun and although the historical setting adds flavor to the story it doesn't overpower it, or require that you know too much about the time period to appreciate what is going on.
Death and grieving are a part of the story, but not the main focus. It is mostly a mystery about both what Aunt Polly has actually done with the secret recipe and whether or not someone is trying to steal the recipe (and who that person might be). The friendship between Alice and Charlie is warm and real, with both ups and downs. The issues that Alice's mother continues to have with Polly illustrate how sibling rivalry is not limited to children. These issues are resolved in a sweet and satisfying way. A lovely novel and a serious contender for a read-aloud during library class next school year.

Countdown

This is a review of the audio book.

Author: Deborah Wiles

Reader: Emma Galvin

Producer: Listening Library

Production Year: 2011

Most of the listeners will be: 4th through 7th grade girls and boys.

Listener's Advisory: Hear about the Cuban Missile Crisis from another perspective (England) in The Fire Eaters by David Almond, also recorded by Listening Library.

Summary:

What could be worse than having your best friend turn on you, your older sister disappearing, your uncle embarrassing you, and your younger brother being so saintly it makes your mistakes look even worse? The President of the United States announcing on TV that Russia is sending missiles to Cuba with the intention of possibly using them on America! Franny Chapman is 11 years old and lives in Maryland during 1962. In addition to her story, we listen to an assortment of documentary materials, including song lyrics, news clips, and biographical sketches of important figures of the time. 

My favorite passage:

Franny's younger brother, Drew is so upset by the news of the Cuban Missile Crisis that he mostly stops eating and hides in his tree house. When Franny goes to talk to him, still holding his favorite book, Our Friend the Atom, he explains that everything we know about atoms could help us get to the moon. But instead we are making atomic bombs and threatening to blow up other people, who are just made of atoms. 

What I really think:

The audio production of this book is phenomenal. There is a kind of channel changing sound between the clips that make up longer documentary sections and different voice actors. There is even some real audio of Kennedy and Khrushchev. 

Personally, I would have liked the biographical sections read by another person, as I associated Galvin's voice with Franny (the book is written in first person). Also, and this must have been a decision by the producer, none of the songs are sung. Why?

Love the story. I mean you see what Drew said about atoms. This book is for the peacemakers.